Whom to choose?
LinkedIn?
Or Facebook?
If you believe in the zero sum game, then we may want to score a pair for LinkedIn in the battle royal between the two social networking sites.
With more users and momentum, Facebook looked like the odds-on favorite for adults, with a more mature sensibility than MySpace. Facebook holds 85% of the college market, and nearly 80% of their audience of almost 40 million users are under the age of 35. That is serious leverage of course. Then there are the business professionals who are willing to leave LinkedIn and to use Facebook for their professional networking. Anecdotal evidence at this time, but consider the case of Jeff Pulver, founder and chairperson of Von, who says "Why use a static site where the fun stops at the profile?" Why indeed?
Seems that LinkedIn was listening. More on that later...
LinkedIn has 17 million members, a 189% increase in users from October 2006 thru October 2007, and allegedly adding 1.1 million users a month. I say allegedly only because on my LinkedIn page. However my personal LinkedIn page listed 25,000 people joining each week, which works out to 100,000 new users a month. However, I noticed that I can not find that link anymore, and my personal network has grown by nearly 8,000 people since January 20, which is still impressive.
And then in the last month, two things have happened. First, Facebook gave LinkedIn some help.
The first problem came with Facebook's News Feeds and mini-Feeds, embedded into user's pages, which would give a user the ability to look at what the user's friends are doing, without actually having to click on the friend's web page. Some Facebook users called this "creepy", he backlash among the students was so pronounced a one day Facebook boycott was called for.
What is interesting, and should have been instructive about the News Feed crisis, is that the information that it was pulling can be gotten by a user with a small amount of work. No truly personal information seemed to be getting transmitted. There does seem to be limits on what users want transmitted.
All of which makes the Beacon crisis truly inexplicable.
Given the problem they had the with NewsFeeds/miniFeeds issue, one would think that in 2008, in the shadow of the Patriot Act, constant threats to personal privacy, identity theft, et al, one would think that security of information would be foremost in the mind of Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg. Even on a social networking site, the most narcissistic user will not blindly give up all access of their personal information.
Alas, Facebook dropped the ball - badly. The Facebook Beacon feature did not initially allow for user control, a problem that created a PR nightmare. Faced with allegations ranging from deceptiveness to out and out invasion of privacy, Zuckerberg announced that he would make Beacon an "opt-in" option rather than "opt-out".
Facebook is clearly taking a beating – hyperbole aside, relinquishment of personal privacy has to remain the option of the user, not the company. The Beacon backlash has already caused Coke-Cola to pull back.
“We have adopted a bit of a ‘wait and see’ as far as what we are going to do with Beacon because we are not sure how consumers are going to respond,” said Carol Kruse, Coke’s vice president of global interactive marketing...“I, like you, certainly understood that it would be opt-in...
Meanwhile, LinkedIn was clearly listening to users.
LinkedIn annouced an API answer to Facebook's Platform with InApps (short for Intelligent Applications). InApps will allow for 1) a group of productivity applications to be developed for LinkedIn, and 2) Allow for the porting of LinkedIn to other applications. Already in place is the alliance between LinkedIn and Business Week. The idea being that a user can read a Business Week article on Keynote Systems, and (assuming that the LinkedIn application is activated) the Keynote contacts that you have in LinkedIn will appear.
Add in a few new features such as the following:
The ability to post your picture on LinkedIn means a more personal touch for LinkedIn users.
The new JobsInsider toolbar that allows IE or Firefox users to search LinkedIn jobs from the browser at anytime.
The new Outlook toolbar that allows a user to update a contact list from Outlook, and seamlessly port in Outlook contacts.
Users can now pull in industry-relevant news reports.
I believe LinkedIn has made serious strides in answering the concerns of current and potential users, combined with the missteps by Facebook, I have to believe that LinkedIn has closed the gap with Facebook.
Having said all of the above, I do not believe that the Facebook/LinkedIn clash has to be a zero-sum endeavor. I'm not the type of guy who wants his social life that close to his business life. I can just see a business contact reading my Facebook page and noting a not-so-businesslike picture from college the day before we conduct business.
I know I am far from alone in saying the following: Instead of choosing between the two, it can be Facebook AND LinkedIn for some people.
But for others, at this time, LinkedIn is looking better.